stricter postfix settings
lschiere at pidgin.im
Sun Jun 13 17:36:54 EDT 2010
On Jun 13, 2010, at 17:22 EDT, Ethan Blanton wrote:
> Paul Aurich spake unto us the following wisdom:
>> At John's suggestion, I'm bringing this up here.
>> It would be nice if the pidgin.im mail servers were a bit more
>> restrictive in what mail they accept. In particular, my
>> (darkrain42.org) mail server is routinely rejecting a message or two
>> coming from bogus domains:
>> postfix/smtpd: NOQUEUE: reject: RCPT from rock.pidgin.im[18.104.22.168]:
>> 450 4.1.8 <apache at localhost.localdomain>: Sender address rejected:
>> Domain not found; from=<apache at localhost.localdomain>
>> to=<paul at darkrain42.org> proto=ESMTP helo=<rock.pidgin.im>
> We have traditionally handled such things with per-user spam filters
> (spamprobe is available on rock, as is spamassassin; the latter can
> check for this condition). I could be convinced to add this
> particular check to the default config, if there's general
> concurrence. I find it annoying, myself, but basically everyone has
> to have their outgoing mail set up to spoof as necessary, anyway,
> since so many servers set it.
>> This is the reject_unknown_sender_domain smtpd_sender_restrictions
>> which I think pidgin.im should add :).
>> There might be other things that could be added (greylisting or pinging
>> an RBL come to mind), but I don't feel as strongly about those.
> I am personally opposed to both of these. Greylisting slows down
> legitimate emails by a potentially long time (if mail servers are set
> conservatively, as they should be, it can reasonably be several
> hours). As far as RBLs ... there are RBLs and then there are RBLs.
> I'd prefer to leave this up to the individual user's spam filters.
> I'll push back on both greylisting and RBLs, but I am ultimately only
> one voice.
at different times I have had greylisting in place. It helps *alot*. But I've turned it off each time due to complaints.
I am against RBLs. I have had a lot of trouble with my own servers being put on RBLs along with entire /24s that I happen to be on. They are an unmitigated pain in the neck, and I will not support them by being a user of them.
More information about the Discussion